Pathways to 100% Renewable Energy in Island Systems: A Systematic Review of Challenges, Solutions Strategies, and Success Cases

The transition to 100% renewable energy systems is critical for achieving global
sustainability and reducing dependence on fossil fuels. Island power systems, due to their geographical isolation, limited interconnectivity, and reliance on imported fuels, face unique challenges in this transition. These systems’ vulnerability to supply–demand imbalances, voltage instability, and frequency deviations necessitates tailored strategies for achieving grid stability. This study conducts a systematic review of the technical and operational challenges associated with transitioning island energy systems to fully renewable
generation, following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and MetaAnalyses (PRISMA) methodology. Out of 991 identified studies, 81 high-quality articles were selected, focusing on key aspects such as grid stability, energy storage technologies, and advanced control strategies. The review highlights the importance of energy storage solutions like battery energy storage systems, hydrogen storage, pumped hydro storage, and flywheels in enhancing grid resilience and supporting frequency and voltage regulation.
Advanced control strategies, including grid-forming and grid-following inverters, as well as digital twins and predictive analytics, emerged as effective in maintaining grid efficiency.
Real-world case studies from islands such as El Hierro, Hawai’i, and Nusa Penida illustrate successful strategies and best practices, emphasizing the role of supportive policies and community engagement. While the findings demonstrate that fully renewable island systems are technically and economically feasible, challenges remain, including regulatory, financial, and policy barriers.